Year Out
I have had an idea. It starts from a simple premise: Some jobs really suck shit.
Crap job number one: being a squaddie. Putting yourself in clear material breech of Commandment Number 6 (don’t kill people) and suffering the serious consequences (eternal torture, no less) in the name of national defence is a crap job. Other crap jobs include: working in Toys R Us at Christmas; stitching garments in an underground sweatshop in East London; cleaning toilets on Virgin Trains in the middle of the night; phoning people up on a Saturday afternoon trying to sell angry people things they don’t want.
Badly paid, badly treated, unappreciated: these are the essential workers who actually make society work. This is a difficult fact to come to terms with if you’re one of the liberal elite trying to dream up ways of making everyone equal. You’re secretly, guiltily, glad it’s ‘them’ who have to do these jobs and not you or your kids.
Progressives try to assuage their guilt by trying to make the work a bit more bearable for the underclass, setting minimum wages and working conditions and so on, and farming out the very crappest jobs to poor countries far across the sea.
But if there was any possibility that they, or their next door neighbour, or their daughter, or someone they might like to invite over for a Martini, might actually have to do a crap job for the rest their lives, they’d run a mile.
For every one person pursuing a life of lofty goals and personal fulfilment there is another one doing a crap job. No-one should have to do a crap job for their entire life: it’s just not fair.
Here’s my idea.
I propose is a kind of conscription where you don’t have to kill people. It’s called a ‘Crap Year’. You do it at the age of 18. Everyone from the duke to the puke has to do a year, maybe two, of the crappest jobs. You work for a pittance doing the things that society desperately needs to have done, but no-one really wants to do. We would have well-staffed nursing homes. Toilets across the country would be spotless. Burgers would be flipped by the big-boned oafish offspring of royalty.
The benefits would be enormous for all concerned. It would mean that the burden for society’s most menial jobs would be shared across all classes and races. It would be the best work experience imaginable. It would be like a proper qualification. It would give employers something by which to actually judge your ability to work.
There could be a whole load of ‘Crap Year Organisations’, devoted to finding fresh-faced young people the crappest employment possible. I’m going to run one, it’s just going to be called ‘CRAP’. I’m going to trademark it tomorrow. New university students could be spared those dire freshers’ anecdotes about yak-milking in the Himalayas. Never again would a blurred photo of a sunset be introduced with the words ‘? and this is when I found myself in Goa’. Everything that needed to be said about the Crap Year could be communicated with a hollow-eyed nod of recognition.
Marx posited a future where the labour-saving devices had reached such efficiency that everyone would have to do very little work in order merely to survive: work would be become something that the individual did for his or her own personal fulfilment, in which ?
“nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity but each can become accomplished in an branch he wishes… to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticize after dinner, just as the have to mind without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, shepherd or critic.”
Marx knew a thing or two about a thing or two. I love him.
Is it a bit like slavery? Some nasty libertarians argue that income tax is a form of slavery. In a sense they’re right. But I draw the opposite conclusion to theirs. We live in a state: get used to it.
Is it conscription? Who cares? I like the idea of conscription. Apart from the fact that the army’s the grisly avatar of our state’s imperialist bent conscription is OK by me. If I thought the army was useful or necessary, I’d be very happy to be conscripted myself. This is a serious idea. I am serious person. Just call me Mao. In the words of a dude with silly facial hair and a devoted fanbase: “Serve the servants.”

Talking about dudes with silly facial hair and devoted fanbases, I saw a documentary about Che Guevara the other night. Even when working in government desk jobs, he seemed to spend a lot of time out in the fields, shirt off, cigar in mouth, helping hack down sugar cane or driving tractors and generally getting his hands dirty. I know this was done for the cameras, partly, but there seemed something pretty genuine in the spirit of it … Not like the British version, some fat Tory in a grey suit and yellow hard hat pretending to lay a couple of bricks for BBC News West before he can get to his canapes and champagne.
I like the idea but I’m not sure they’d go for it. ‘they’ being politicians of course ( I hardly think Gordon’ll be up for sending his sprog off to scrub public toilets when he reaches voting age, Tone might be more up for it as Euan’s already at uni, but he’s still got the other two to think of. I’m not sure that young new voters would be particularly appreciative either of a government that would force them to scrape chewing gum off the streets in the rain for a year while being paid a pittance!)
Also you should consider those people who actually have very limited job skills and would actually find it hard to handle anything other than a comparitavely crap job. Would they end up unemployed? or perhaps yak farmers…
Is the army less useful than telesales? Really? They probably cause as much pain and suffering to everyone involved.
That typed,it’s not a bad idea, but unfortunatly, the vast, vast majority of jobs are crap jobs. Having a crap year is a clever bit of sleight of hand as it suggests that the job you get after university won’t be crap. We’ve been seduced by the idea that work should or can be personally fulfilling. It would be nice if it was but its not really possible for 95% of jobs. Unless you start adjusting your personality so that filing or selling a certain pair of shoes makes you happy.
I think part of the genuine spirit of Che Guevara was that he liked having his shirt off in a field.
Don’t we all?
The other day, whilst hating ‘boys’ I said to my dad that I wished I could go out with Che Guevara and wouldn’t it be exciting? (the cigar, the beard) and my dad just said ‘You might be a bit sad now’. Don’t forget that in the olden days when everyone did Che it about in fields they thought wouldn’t it be exciting to have a train, and a watch, and an office, and they sodding built it all and were well pleased with themselves an all.
The only way office jobs can be fulfilling is if you become addicted to the internet, and specifically looking up trivia about David Bowie on the internet. I think eveyone should be forced to research David Bowie, for a year, on the internet. And I particularly think that someone, should make a spoof sketch of Alien extending his microscopic mouths, on and on, until his last mouth is the size of a pea, and he pecks like a gnat at your arm with it, whilst his huge alien body goes crazy in the background. And eats peas off a plate.
Bowie rules ok!